Mining often sets increase a straight competition with small-scale farming for control of land.

“Si a la vida, no a la mina” (Yes to life, no come the mine) is a rallying cry heard throughout many components of rural Latin America these days. Mining, and also oil and also gas extraction, has actually exploded throughout the an ar in the critical decade, thrust by high prices for gold and industrial steels like copper that space needed primarily to feeding the Chinese economy. This eight has also been skilled in Africa and also Asia, where governments have search to make use of their resource endowments to drive development. Fragile states favor Sudan, Burma and Afghanistan have likewise begun to construct their mining sectors. The expanding mining sector has added to solid economic development in part countries yet has additionally generated social conflicts in rural areas that have to be urgently addressed.

You are watching: What brought conflict between mining companies and farmers

*
Area near Tintaya Copper Mine (Espinar), Cusco, Peru. Photo: chris Hufstader / Oxfam America

The love of the concern is the mining activity has come into direct competition with an additional predominant method of economic development in rural areas: small-scale agriculture. Emphasize over control of soil and, most importantly, water have actually led to ar protests and also violent conflict. Reconciling these two important breakthrough drivers has end up being a an essential governance issue, an especially in the most fragile states whereby the conflicts between the 2 can often be seen most starkly.

In theory, both mining and farming can carry out pathways out of poverty. The World Bank and development-focused scholastic researchers have emphasized the crucial role of agriculture in fostering rural development. (Three-quarters that the world’s negative live in countryside areas.) Agriculture provides straight benefits to those who communicate in it. Farmers receive payments for plants they produce, i beg your pardon they deserve to then usage to invest in future production and also to salary for their families’ basic needs. Mining can additionally play a role in promoting development, although more indirectly, by generating revenues for governments. Governments deserve to use taxes and also royalties paid by mining suppliers for facilities investments and also other productive purposes. Mining companies likewise pay because that community development programs, develop schools and roads, and also make various other investments.

Unfortunately, the compatibility of this two breakthrough paths, which tend to take ar in the very same rural areas, is at finest questionable. Mining generates significant “externalities,” e.g. Water pollution, that deserve to have a direct impact on farming production. These negative impacts can be permanent and render previously fertile agricultural land unusable. Mining likewise requires big amounts of soil that can otherwise be supplied for farming production. This sets increase a straight competition with small-scale farming for control and use the land. In some countries such as Ghana, farmer displaced by mining jobs turn come small-scale mining as a instead of livelihood. This can perpetuate a bike of poverty and also conflict in which this farmers-turned-miners are forcibly evicted and beaten by police because that coming top top land declared by massive mining projects.

Mining companies argue the mining and agriculture are no necessarily incompatible. However there are couple of examples of whereby this has actually been the case, particularly in arising countries, where oversight the the mining market is often really weak. Finding methods to reconcile these 2 economic tasks is urgently necessary to minimize conflicts and ensure that mining’s benefits add to permanent sustainable advance in rural economies.

*
Communities relocated come make means for gold mines in Ghana struggle with loss of farming land, unemployment, and environmental damage. Photo: Neil Brander / Oxfam America

Governments and also companies have to take certain steps currently to address this situation. First, the environmental influence assessment process for mining projects needs to be significantly strengthened and also made an ext independent. At present, federal governments rely top top information noted by companies, i m sorry is most regularly not the evaluation by an independent third-party. Carriers thus have actually an incentive to downplay potential effects of your operations top top land and water in farming areas. In countries such as Peru, local agricultural communities’ lack of trust in these ecological reviews contributes to anxieties around the effects of mining, which in turn contributes to conflict. Additionally, mining is progressively done in “clusters,” an interpretation several mines operate in the same geographical area in order to take advantage of shared infrastructure and processing facilities. The cumulative impacts on land and also water of numerous mines operating in the very same area have not been thoroughly examined. The use of what are well-known as “strategic” environmental impact assessments, i m sorry take into account these cumulative impacts, would be an essential step to raising communities’ confidence.

Improved planning on just how land will certainly be used is another an important step that federal governments should take. Mining concessions are regularly awarded without consideration for results on agricultural production. Later this year Oxfam America will publish research study that shows graphically just how mining and also oil concessions have actually expanded significantly in recent years in agriculturally productive locations of Peru and Ghana. Zoning soil for specific uses, e.g. Mining or agriculture, would assist reduce problem by establishing clear rules for exactly how land will be used. Greater dialogue between the mining and agricultural sectors would be helpful. In Peru recently, the mining and agriculture ministries have actually signed a collaboration agreement. This is potentially a positive, although overdue, step.

Reconciling mining with agriculture in emerging countries, an especially in the most fragile states, won’t be easy. It may ultimately require the join that the two merely are incompatible over the irreversible in specific areas. What is clean is the these discussions room urgently essential now so the conflict and violence created by the location junxtap of these two sectors diminishes and also that countries can benefit from both their above-and below-the-ground resources.

See more: 210+ Songs With The Word Color In The Title (By Genre), Songs With A Colour In The Title: A Handy List

This post originally showed up on the blog of the us Institute of Peace’s International Network because that Economics and also Conflict.