The Federal strength to tax The Issues: How much does the strength of congress "to lay and also collect taxes" extend?
introduction The United states is a government of enumerated powers. Congress, and also the various other two branches that the federal government, can only practice those powers given in the Constitution.

You are watching: Congress may impose a tax on exports

The powers of Congress space enumerated in several areas in the Constitution. The most important listing of congressional powers appears in article I, ar 8 (see left) which identifies in seventeen paragraphs numerous important strength of Congress. In this section, we take into consideration how the enumerated strength of conference "to lay and also collect taxes" has been interpreted.

Article I, section 8 offers Congress the strength to "lay and also collect taxes, duties, imports, and also excises." The Constitution permits Congress to tax in order to "provide because that the common defense and general welfare." The Court has actually flip-flopped on the concern of whether Congress has actually the constitutional strength to tax in bespeak to achieve regulatory objectives that would certainly otherwise be external of the scope of that enumerated powers. In Bailey vs Drexel Furniture (1922), the Court invalidated a 10% taxation on the annual profits the employers who knowingly employ kid labor. The tax, imposed after an previously attempt to block the federal government transportation and also sale of commodities produced by kid labor to be struck down in Hammer, was checked out by the Court together an unconstitutional attempt to make an end-run about its previously decision. In 1925, in Linder v unified States, the Court reversed the conviction of a medical professional who had given three cocaine tablet computers to a patience to relax an addiction. The conviction, based on a regulation that imposed a $3 taxes on doctors who prescribed cocaine, rested on the concept that the law minimal the prescription of cocaine come the therapy of diseases, not addictions, and also that the defendant had provided cocaine tablets to one addict. The Court concluded that the law can survive just as a revenue measure, and also that the taxing Power offered Congress no authority to regulate straight the practice of medicine--that is, to tell physicians who had paid the compelled tax what they have the right to or cannot do for their patients. The Court reversed its half on taxes serving mainly regulatory (rather 보다 revenue-producing) purposes in Steward maker (1937), which upheld a taxes on employers designed to encourage states to enact unemployment compensation schemes. In Kahriger (1953), the Court upheld a regulation requiring bookies come register and also pay on taxation on every wagers--even though the tax had the regulatory goal of wiping the end bookmaking operations and also could not be supposed to produce significant revenue.
The Affordable Health care Act ("Obamacare") survived, mostly, when 5 justices found "the separation, personal, instance mandate" come be within the taxing power of Congress.
In possibly the most significant taxing power instance ever decided, the Court ruled in nationwide Federation the Independent organization v Sebelius (2012) that the so-called "individual mandate" (generally thought about a need that people purchase health and wellness insurance) consisted of in the Affordable care Act might be continual as a tax, also though the requirement was external of Congress"s power to regulate commerce. Creating for five members that the Court, chief Justice Roberts hosted that also though advocates of the Act continuously said a penalty, not a tax, would apply to individuals who failure to purchase insurance, that still operated together a tax and also that a functional analysis should control. The Court noted that failure to acquisition insurance compelled a payment to the IRS, that no criminal penalties attached to failure to purchase insurance, and that the cost of the tax would, in many cases, be much less than the expense of purchase insurance. In sum, the regulation did not make that unlawful to acquisition insurance, allowing individuals a selection of paying a taxation instead. Roberts likewise reaffirmed the the Congress might seek to attain regulatory purposes through the taxing power that it could not it is in able to attain under that is other short article I powers. Judge Kennedy, Alito, Scalia, and Thomas dissented, saying that the count power could not sustain the mandate.

other Pages Relating come the Powers that Congress: The Necessary and Proper Clause The Federal commerce Power The safety Power Powerto enforce the protections the the 13th, 14th, and 15th Amendments 10th and 11th Amendment constraints on the powers of Congress The commerce Clause as a Limitation top top State strength

The strength to tax: Bailey v Drexel Furniture (1922) Linder v United says (1925) Steward an equipment vs Davis (1937) U.S. Vs Kahriger (1953) nationwide Federation of Independent service v Sebelius (2012)<"individual mandate" case>
vital Constitutional grants of strength to conference TAXING POWER The congress shall have actually Power come lay and also collect Taxes, Duties, Imposts and Excises, to pay the debts and carry out for the typical Defence and also general Welfare the the joined States...

Article I, Section. 8.

See more: Can Someone Explain To Me How To Play 2 Player On Minecraft Ps3 ?

The congress shall have actually Power to lay and collect Taxes, Duties, Imposts and also Excises, to pay the fan and provide for the common Defence and also general Welfare the the united States; but all Duties, Imposts and Excises shall it is in uniform transparent the united States;

To loaned Money on the credit of the united States;

To regulate commerce with international Nations, and among the number of States, and with the Indian Tribes;

To develop an uniform preeminence of Naturalization, and also uniform legislations on the topic of Bankruptcies transparent the united States;

To coin Money, manage the value thereof, and also of international Coin, and fix the typical of Weights and Measures;

To provide for the penalty of counterfeiting the Securities and also current Coin of the united States;

To establish write-up Offices and post Roads;

To encourage the development of Science and useful Arts, through securing for limited Times come Authors and also Inventors the exclusive ideal to their corresponding Writings and also Discoveries;

To constitute Tribunals inferior to the supreme Court;

To define and punish Piracies and also Felonies cursed on the high Seas, and Offences against the law of Nations;

To declare War, approve Letters of Marque and also Reprisal, and also make rule concerning catches on Land and also Water;

To raise and support Armies, however no Appropriation of Money to that usage shall be for a longer Term than 2 Years;

To carry out and keep a Navy;

To make Rules for the Government and Regulation of the land and also naval Forces;

To carry out for calling soon the Militia to execute the legislations of the Union, suppress Insurrections and also repel Invasions;

To administer for organizing, arming, and disciplining, the Militia, and for governing such component of lock as may be employed in the company of the joined States, reserving come the says respectively, the appointment of the Officers, and the authority of cultivate the Militia follow to the discipline prescribed through Congress;

To practice exclusive law in all situations whatsoever, over such ar (not exceeding ten mile square) as may, by Cession of specific States, and the accept of Congress, become the seat of the government of the joined States, and also to exercise like Authority end all locations purchased through the Consent of the legislature of the State in which the exact same shall be, for the Erection the Forts, Magazines, Arsenals, dock-Yards, and also other needful Buildings;--And

To make all regulations which shall be necessary and also proper because that carrying into Execution the foregoing Powers, and all various other Powers forgive by this constitution in the federal government of the unified States, or in any type of Department or Officer thereof.



1. Does Congress have the power to taxes for a purely regulatory, non-revenue raising, goal? can Congress call for all prostitute to register and pay a taxation if it might not make prostitution a federal crime directly? 2. Go the Court"s decision in nationwide Federation that Independent business v Sebelius suggest that congress will increasingly rely ~ above its taxing strength to attain goals it might not be able to achieve under its commerce power? 3. Carry out you think the the description of a system in an act as a "penalty" not a "tax" should control, or was the Court correct to use a functional analysis to conclude the the separation, personal, instance mandate penalty/tax operated together a tax--no criminal punishment, for example, for not purchasing health and wellness insurance so long as you make the payment come the IRS (and the amount payment will generally be much less than the cost of insurance)?